Apple Asks Supreme Court to Throw Out App Store Contempt Ruling - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Apple Asks Supreme Court to Throw Out App Store Contempt Ruling

Apple today filed its opening merits brief with the Supreme Court as it prepares to fight the contempt ruling that forced it to change its App Store rules. Apple is asking the Supreme Court to reverse or vacate the contempt order, which would return the ‌App Store‌ to its pre–2025 rules.

app store blue banner epic 1
The Supreme Court filing is part of Apple's ongoing legal battle with Epic Games, which has gotten more and more complicated since it kicked off in 2020. Apple largely won the original ruling because it wasn't found to have violated antitrust law, but Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, the judge overseeing the case, ordered Apple to relax its anti-steering rules and let developers link to alternative purchase options in apps.

Apple complied, but charged a 12 to 27 percent fee on link-outs, and few developers adopted the system. Epic went back to Gonzalez Rogers and said Apple violated her injunction, and she agreed. In April 2025, she found Apple in contempt of court and barred the company from collecting any fees on purchases made through links in the U.S. ‌App Store‌.

Apple changed its ‌App Store‌ rules to comply with the new ruling but appealed. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the contempt finding, and Apple appealed to the Supreme Court.

Today's brief repeats Apple's main argument and asks the Supreme Court to decide whether a court can hold a party in civil contempt for violating the "spirit" of an injunction when the injunction does not address the conduct the contempt ruling is based on.

The first injunction from Gonzalez Rogers had no mention of the fees Apple was or wasn't allowed to charge, but both the original contempt ruling and the court of appeals agreed Apple had violated the "spirit" of the injunction when it charged fees that were too high.

Citing cases dating back to 1885, Apple argues the Ninth Circuit broke with precedent when it said Apple could be held in contempt for violating the spirit of an injunction. Apple says it cannot be held in contempt because there was no clear and unambiguous violation of the injunction's wording. Apple repeatedly points out the original injunction was just 75 words long.

The Supreme Court is expected to hear the case in 2027. ‌Epic Games‌ will submit its response brief in November, and then Apple will be able to submit a reply brief.

While Apple waits for the Supreme Court, it will be going back to district court for fee calculations that would be implemented if the higher court does not toss out the contempt ruling and resulting anti-steering order. Apple was ordered back to district court because the appeals court found the district court's total ban on commissions went too far, and sent it back to set a reasonable fee. Apple attempted to delay the proceedings but was unsuccessful.

Note: This discussion thread is located in our Political News forum with special rules.

Popular Stories

Apple Creator Studio iWork suite

Apple Pulls Keynote, Pages and Numbers From App Store [Update: Back]

Thursday October 22, 2026 11:01 am PDT by
Apple has temporarily removed Keynote, Pages, and Numbers from the App Store, just after releasing an update that added iPhone Duo support and a new Intelligent Assistant. It is not clear if the apps were removed intentionally, or if it is a bug. Apple has not said when the apps will be reinstated, but if it was in error, they should return soon. Update: The Mac versions are back without...
iPhone Duo Apps feature

Apple Reveals More Than 50 Apps That Will Be Updated for iPhone Duo

Thursday October 22, 2026 6:04 am PDT by
Apple today highlighted more than 50 third-party App Store apps that are or will soon be fully optimized for the iPhone Duo and its various layouts and poses. You can hold the iPhone Duo and set it down in a number of ways, such as partially folded like a book, placed down on a surface, or standing on its edges: With the Netflix app, for example, Apple said iPhone Duo users can scroll...
Apple Says Over 100000 Apps Optimized for iPhone Duo But These Are Still Missing Feature 1

Apple Says More Than 100,000 Apps Optimized for iPhone Duo, Here's What's Still Missing

Friday November 6, 2026 9:18 am PST by
Apple today announced that more than 100,000 apps have been optimized for the iPhone Duo, released two weeks ago. We confirmed that this figure refers to apps built with the iOS 27.1 SDK or later, meaning these apps fill the full width of the iPhone Duo's inner and outer displays and have vertical controls in the status bar. A statement from Susan Prescott, Apple's Vice President of...

Top Rated Comments

9 weeks ago

YEAH IT'S THEIR STORE AND THEY CAN DO WHATEVER THEY WANT !
The App Store is the major gateway to the large, lucrative iOS/iPhone market, and the primary way developers access that market. Apple can set certain rules for its store but if/when those rules significantly affect competition, consumer choice, etc. they can be subject to varying antitrust/competition laws and regulations. Just because it's "their store" doesn't give them total freedom to do whatever they want with it.
Score: 7 Votes (Like | Disagree)
9 weeks ago

The Supreme Court filing is part of Apple's ongoing legal battle with Epic Games, which has gotten more and more complicated since it kicked off in 2020. Apple largely won the original ruling because it wasn't found to have violated antitrust law, but Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, the judge overseeing the case, ordered Apple to relax its anti-steering rules ('https://www.macrumors.com/2021/09/10/epic-games-vs-apple-decision/') and let developers link to alternative purchase options in apps.

Apple complied, but charged a 12 to 27 percent fee on link-outs, and few developers adopted the system. Epic went back to Gonzalez Rogers and said Apple violated her injunction, and she agreed. In April 2025, she found Apple in contempt of court ('https://www.macrumors.com/2025/04/30/apple-app-store-anti-steering-injunction-violation/') and barred the company from collecting any fees on purchases made through links in the U.S. App Store.
There’s some more legal context here that’s important. If Apple felt the judge’s injunction wasn’t clear enough, Apple simply could’ve asked the judge to clarify her injunction. Litigants frequently ask judges for clarification, and Apple has done that before. But Apple didn’t do that on this occasion. In fact, usually the way this works is that the judge asks the winning party to draft her order (subject to her review and possible editing) but to confer with the other party to check if they can agree on specific language or at least narrow their differences.

If there was any ambiguity in this injunction, Apple wanted it that way or at least tolerated it.

Also, both the trial judge and the Ninth Circuit have ruled that Apple did NOT comply with the judge's injunction. Thus it's legally factually incorrect to write "Apple complied" unless and until the Supreme Court rules that Apple complied.
Score: 5 Votes (Like | Disagree)
9 weeks ago

Meh, their phone, their store, their business… not happy? Go to android !
If having an alternative or alternatives is basically all that matters then if Apple is not happy with the "rules" in certain states, provinces, countries, etc. perhaps they can go (or continue to do business) elsewhere. California is only one of 50 states. The U.S. is only one of nearly 200 countries. There are MANY "alternatives" for Apple.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
danpass Avatar
9 weeks ago
The "spirit" of the law is NEVER applied against the state .... so it should never be applied against the defendant.

Ask any lawyer when the "spirit" of the law applies.

:crickets"

IANAL but this should have been crushed by the 9th Circuit. But I guess that's why it's called the 9th Circus.

-
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
jz0309 Avatar
9 weeks ago
and so it continues, I can't wait for this to come to an end so I don't have to look for "Epic" stories on MR anymore, but knowing them ... oh one can dream ...
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Mrkevinfinnerty Avatar
9 weeks ago

No, for fall detection you don’t need your phone if you have a cell chip. Thought that was common knowledge?
Good luck setting that up without an iPhone 👍



Attachment Image
Score: 2 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
Apple Black Friday Starts Early: Save on Apple Watch, MacBook Air, and More
Apple Black Friday Starts Early: Save on Apple Watch, MacBook Air, and More
13 hours ago
Top Stories: Apple's New Software Approach, iPhone Duo-Optimized Apps, and More
Top Stories: Apple's New Software Approach, iPhone Duo-Optimized Apps, and More
14 hours ago
HomeView Tidbits: Mirror, Sleep Timer, and Other Details
HomeView Tidbits: Mirror, Sleep Timer, and Other Details
1 day ago
Siri AI Still Not Enabled on HomePod Mini 2 With Latest Software Update
Siri AI Still Not Enabled on HomePod Mini 2 With Latest Software Update
1 day ago
Apple Releases tvOS 27.2.1 With Siri AI for Older Apple TVs
Apple Releases tvOS 27.2.1 With Siri AI for Older Apple TVs
1 day ago
Microsoft 365 Outage Resolving After Nearly 24 Hours
Microsoft 365 Outage Resolving After Nearly 24 Hours
1 day ago
iPhone Duo Survives 450,000 Folds, but Hinge is Weakening
iPhone Duo Survives 450,000 Folds, but Hinge is Weakening
1 day ago
Apple TV 4K Launch Day Deal Arrives at Amazon
Apple TV 4K Launch Day Deal Arrives at Amazon
1 day ago
The MacRumors Show: HomeView and Apple TV 4K First Impressions
The MacRumors Show: HomeView and Apple TV 4K First Impressions
1 day ago
YouTube App Not Working on Your New Apple TV? Here's the Fix
YouTube App Not Working on Your New Apple TV? Here's the Fix
1 day ago
Apple Meets Thai Officials Over iPhone Spyware Warnings
Apple Meets Thai Officials Over iPhone Spyware Warnings
2 days ago
Apple Shares HomeView 27.2 Release Notes With List of Features
Apple Shares HomeView 27.2 Release Notes With List of Features
2 days ago
HomeView in Québec: Apple Says Canadian French Support to Arrive in Software Update
HomeView in Québec: Apple Says Canadian French Support to Arrive in Software Update
2 days ago
Apple Watch Ultra 3 Gets Big $250 Discounts Ahead of Black Friday
Apple Watch Ultra 3 Gets Big $250 Discounts Ahead of Black Friday
2 days ago
Apple Says HomeView Sets New Record in Design-Focused Interview
Apple Says HomeView Sets New Record in Design-Focused Interview
2 days ago
Best Apple Deals of the Week: AirTag 2 Hits Record Low Price, Plus Early Black Friday Sales
Best Apple Deals of the Week: AirTag 2 Hits Record Low Price, Plus Early Black Friday Sales
2 days ago
iPhone 18 and 18e Coming in Spring 2027 With A20 Chip
iPhone 18 and 18e Coming in Spring 2027 With A20 Chip
2 days ago
King Charles to Join Elton John's Apple Music Radio Show
King Charles to Join Elton John's Apple Music Radio Show
2 days ago
Select 'Apple Home Collection' Accessories Now Available to Order
Select 'Apple Home Collection' Accessories Now Available to Order
2 days ago
Major Microsoft 365 Outage Continues
Major Microsoft 365 Outage Continues
2 days ago
Apple Launches Two Products Today
Apple Launches Two Products Today
2 days ago
Hands-On With the New Apple TV 4K and Siri AI
Hands-On With the New Apple TV 4K and Siri AI
2 days ago
Siri AI Coming to Older Apple TV 4K Models in tvOS 27.2.1
Siri AI Coming to Older Apple TV 4K Models in tvOS 27.2.1
2 days ago
HomeView Launch Kicks Off as First Orders Reach Customers
HomeView Launch Kicks Off as First Orders Reach Customers
2 days ago
Apple Continues to Move Up iPhone Duo Delivery Dates
Apple Continues to Move Up iPhone Duo Delivery Dates
2 days ago
Apple Explains How HomeView Keeps Camera Data Private
Apple Explains How HomeView Keeps Camera Data Private
2 days ago
Apple Releases Updated HomeView Software 27.2 Before Launch
Apple Releases Updated HomeView Software 27.2 Before Launch
2 days ago
Apple Adds Samsung Foldables to Trade-In Program
Apple Adds Samsung Foldables to Trade-In Program
3 days ago
Apple Sports App Now Features UFC
Apple Sports App Now Features UFC
3 days ago
Trump Says Tim Cook Should Be Nvidia CEO as Jensen Huang Resigns
Trump Says Tim Cook Should Be Nvidia CEO as Jensen Huang Resigns
3 days ago