ITC Rules For Apple in HTC Patent Case [Updated] - MacRumors
Skip to Content

ITC Rules For Apple in HTC Patent Case [Updated]

United States International Trade Commission sealA judge with the US International Trade Commission ruled today that HTC violated two of Apple's patents in a year-long case filed last March. Apple had accused HTC of violating 20 of its patents, and filed a second complaint this week, claiming infringement of five more patents. HTC has said it will appeal the decision.

When it initially filed the lawsuit, Apple CEO Steve Jobs explained why it was taking legal action:

We can sit by and watch competitors steal our patented inventions, or we can do something about it. We’ve decided to do something about it. We think competition is healthy, but competitors should create their own original technology, not steal ours.

If HTC's appeal fails, it will be required to settle with Apple over the patents. However, FOSS Patents' Florian Mueller notes the ITC decision could be very bad for Android, if Apple refuses to settle:

Depending on which two patents HTC infringes and on whether the Commission affirms the ALJ's decision, this could in a worst-case scenario result in a shutdown of many or even all Android-based HTC products in the U.S. market. In a less extreme scenario, HTC might have to remove certain functionality from its products, and that could result in a significant degradation of the user experience and quality of those devices.

Mueller notes that Apple has two ITC complaints and three federal lawsuits currently in motion against HTC, with 16 other patents in question aside from the ones in today's decision.

The United States International Trade Commission is an independent federal agency that, among other things, adjudicates cases involving imports that allegedly infringe intellectual property rights." It has the power, in rare cases, to ban infringing products from the country entirely.

Update: These are the two patents the judge feels are being infringed:

- U.S. Patent No. 5,946,647 on a "system and method causes a computer to detect and perform actions on structures identified in computer data."

- U.S. Patent No. 6,343,263 on a "data transmission system having a real-time data engine for processing isochronous streams of data includes an interface device that provides a physical and logical connection of a computer to any one or more of a variety of different types of data networks."

Both of these patents are at issue in the lawsuits between Apple and Motorola as well.

Popular Stories

Apple 2026 Black Friday Event Hero

Apple Announces 2026 Black Friday Event, Here's What You Can Get

Thursday November 19, 2026 9:11 am PST by
Apple's annual four-day Black Friday through Cyber Monday shopping event is returning on Friday, November 27 through Monday, November 30 in many countries, including the United States, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, the United Kingdom, Belgium, the Netherlands, Sweden, Thailand, and others. In the U.S., Apple's terms and conditions say the promotion begins on...
bug security vulnerability issue fix larry

iPhone Users Targeted in Major Website Security Breach

Tuesday November 17, 2026 4:41 am PST by
Hackers used some of the world's most popular websites to distribute malware designed to steal cryptocurrency and exploit vulnerabilities in iPhones and iPads this week, according to a new security investigation. Reuters reports that websites associated with 178 organizations were affected by the attack on Monday, November 16, including the likes of Zoom, BBC, CNN, HSBC, Salesforce, and...
apple design award 2025

Apple Announces 2025 Design Award Winners Ahead of WWDC 2025

Tuesday June 3, 2025 10:14 am PDT by
As we wait for WWDC to kick off next Monday, Apple today announced the winners of its annual Apple Design Awards, recognizing apps and games for their innovation, ingenuity, and technical achievement. The 2025 Apple Design Award winners are listed below, with one app and one game selected per category: Delight and Fun - CapWords (App) and Balatro (Game) Innovation - Play (App) and PBJ -...

Top Rated Comments

gkpm Avatar
200 months ago
Good luck to Apple for defending that patent - my Samsung Windows Mobile SCH-i730 phone from 2005 did exactly the same thing - text in email/SMS messages was hot-linked to the obvious....

Apple has good photo-copiers - but they'll need a real time machine to defend this patent.
Or Apple just had to file it before your 2005 phone, which they did, the patent was filed in 1996.
Score: 13 Votes (Like | Disagree)
LimeiBook86 Avatar
200 months ago
Good for Apple, they should stick up for their patents. It'll be very interesting to see what happens with this. It's taken so long to come to this stage, so we may have to wait even longer to discover what happens next.
Score: 11 Votes (Like | Disagree)
mdriftmeyer Avatar
200 months ago
There are lots of patent "trolls". There are painfully few patent rights licensing "trolls".

Rocketman

Exploit the world, don't improve it!

It's called competition on a level playing field. HTC has equal rights to patent their IP and defend it against Apple or any other competitor.

Either one can invest into R&D and actually hire professionals to do the research or risk legal action for IP theft.

It appears this generation thinks now, more than ever, that IP theft is virtuous and investing in the education of a growing technical staff is not an action of virtue.
Score: 10 Votes (Like | Disagree)
200 months ago
It's totally not about that.

It's your stupid dilemma that Apple is the only one in the right mind, patenting the right ****, doing the right **** for the consumers.
No doubt that Apple is definitely doing so; but there are a ton of companies that are trying to do so as well.

I am very happy that Apple finally holds a candle with these patents and trying to force HTC to get into a patent license agreement which has been literally 'stealing' some of the patents from Apple(no doubt Apple does 'steal' too).

Point being, you make it sound so ridiculous that Apple patented all the features of the smartphone and all companies are left naked, now to suck Apple's balls and will get sued by Apple until they go bankrupt.

Seriously, get off the 'Fanboy bandwagon'. I have stated before that I do like some of your posts, but your ridiculous insight to the Godlike Apple and ****-like other companies is very disgusting to read.

Apple may well being doing good; but they are not the only one innovating or doing good. Get a thought please; this time around a decent one.

Wow, this has really thrown you off your rocker...

No, Apple isn't the only one doing great stuff in the mobile platform. You can look at Palm (HP) and MS (honestly, WP7 is pretty good) who are doing new, interesting stuff. However, Android was a total rip-off of a LOT of things. Apple's design, and smartphone concept, in the user facing areas, and Java in the fundamentals.
Score: 10 Votes (Like | Disagree)
200 months ago
I am in favor of the filings and rulings, but the whole principal of patent law is not to prevent folks from using intellectual property, but paying for it. The outcome here will not be exclusion of products or of usage rights, but compensation for same.

Apple values exclusivity over money so despite fully winning they lost.

Rocketman

Insight over noise.

I agree. Apple should licence those patents on a fair and reasonable basis. They should be awarded some retroactive money based on historical sales, and HTC should be made to pay Apple an additional punitive amount based on damages to Apple.

However, they should not be prevented from selling their phones. That is not the point of the patent process.
Score: 10 Votes (Like | Disagree)
mdriftmeyer Avatar
200 months ago
Hilarious coming from a man (who I idolize) that stole all his ideas from Xerox. Too funny drill Sgt!

For someone who claims they idolize the man you have zero knowledge of the relation that was PARC and Apple.

XEROX got $125 Million in stock they immediately sold when Apple had their IPO.

If they held onto it it would be in the tens of billions, in today's valuation.

XEROX licensed their IP to Apple and had no interest in the personal computer paradigm. They were the fools.
Score: 9 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
Apple Black Friday Deals Available Now: AirPods, Apple Watches, MacBooks, and More
Apple Black Friday Deals Available Now: AirPods, Apple Watches, MacBooks, and More
1 hour ago
First Look at iPhone Air 2 and iPhone 18 Revealed By Dummy Models
First Look at iPhone Air 2 and iPhone 18 Revealed By Dummy Models
2 hours ago
WhatsApp Raises Group Chat Limit to 1,500 Members
WhatsApp Raises Group Chat Limit to 1,500 Members
3 hours ago
MacBook Pro Black Friday Deals Are Here: Get Up to $250 Off M6 and PROLED XDR
MacBook Pro Black Friday Deals Are Here: Get Up to $250 Off M6 and PROLED XDR
17 hours ago
Apple is Building an AI Agent That Can Use Apps and Code
Apple is Building an AI Agent That Can Use Apps and Code
17 hours ago
Black Friday Deal: Apple TV Streaming Service for $6.99/Month
Black Friday Deal: Apple TV Streaming Service for $6.99/Month
18 hours ago
AirPods Black Friday Deals Hit Pro 3 at $179 and Max 2 at $429
AirPods Black Friday Deals Hit Pro 3 at $179 and Max 2 at $429
18 hours ago
Second iOS 27.3 and macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Public Betas Now Available
Second iOS 27.3 and macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Public Betas Now Available
18 hours ago
Google's Gemini Can Now Control Apps on Your Mac
Google's Gemini Can Now Control Apps on Your Mac
20 hours ago
iPhone Duo vs. Samsung Galaxy Z Fold8: Which is Better?
iPhone Duo vs. Samsung Galaxy Z Fold8: Which is Better?
22 hours ago
Apple Executive in Charge of iPhone's Camera App Reportedly Retires
Apple Executive in Charge of iPhone's Camera App Reportedly Retires
22 hours ago
Apple Announces 2026 Black Friday Event, Here's What You Can Get
Apple Announces 2026 Black Friday Event, Here's What You Can Get
23 hours ago
Sonos Black Friday Sale Takes Up to 25% Off Speakers, Soundbars, and More
Sonos Black Friday Sale Takes Up to 25% Off Speakers, Soundbars, and More
23 hours ago
Apple TV to Stream Female 'F1 Academy' Races in U.S. Starting in 2027
Apple TV to Stream Female 'F1 Academy' Races in U.S. Starting in 2027
23 hours ago
Tomorrow Marks the End of a 28-Year Era at Apple
Tomorrow Marks the End of a 28-Year Era at Apple
1 day ago
Amazon Takes $200 Off Every Apple Studio Display for Black Friday
Amazon Takes $200 Off Every Apple Studio Display for Black Friday
1 day ago
UK Loses Secrecy Fight Over Apple 'Backdoor' Order
UK Loses Secrecy Fight Over Apple 'Backdoor' Order
1 day ago
Beats 360 Black Friday Deal Arrives With Massive $100 Discount on Amazon
Beats 360 Black Friday Deal Arrives With Massive $100 Discount on Amazon
1 day ago
Apple Music Radio Now Reaches Over 50 Million Monthly Listeners
Apple Music Radio Now Reaches Over 50 Million Monthly Listeners
1 day ago
Future Macs Could Get Brighter, Longer-Lasting OLED Displays in 2030
Future Macs Could Get Brighter, Longer-Lasting OLED Displays in 2030
1 day ago
Apple Faces 'Planned Obsolescence' Trial Over iPhone Repairs
Apple Faces 'Planned Obsolescence' Trial Over iPhone Repairs
1 day ago
Apple May Cancel OLED iMac
Apple May Cancel OLED iMac
1 day ago
Instagram Now Lets You Save Songs to Apple Music
Instagram Now Lets You Save Songs to Apple Music
2 days ago
Apple Releases Safari Technology Preview 257 With Bug Fixes and Performance Improvements
Apple Releases Safari Technology Preview 257 With Bug Fixes and Performance Improvements
2 days ago
HomeView 27.2.1 Update Fixes Siri Bugs
HomeView 27.2.1 Update Fixes Siri Bugs
2 days ago
Apple Card Offers New Users Double Daily Cash for a Year
Apple Card Offers New Users Double Daily Cash for a Year
2 days ago
Apple Releases 27.2.1 HomeView Software Update
Apple Releases 27.2.1 HomeView Software Update
2 days ago
Amazon Offering $100 Off Nearly All M4 iPad Air Models
Amazon Offering $100 Off Nearly All M4 iPad Air Models
2 days ago
Apple's Fall Creator Studio Updates Now Live
Apple's Fall Creator Studio Updates Now Live
2 days ago
iPhone 20 Pro Rumored to Return to Titanium
iPhone 20 Pro Rumored to Return to Titanium
2 days ago